How can you maximize your social security bend points?
Do you want to retire early but still get as much social security as possible?
If so, you should understand the bend points of social security. Most financial planners don’t even understand the bend points. But the long and the short of it is—not every year worked has the same payout to you in SS benefits!
What are the social security bend points, and how many years do you need to work to maximize them?
Social Security Wage Base Impacts Bend Points
Let’s start with a few introductory comments, because you need to understand a little about social security before we can go right to the bend points.
First off, meet the social security wage base. Each year, there is a limit after which you stop paying FICA taxes and you accumulate no further social security benefits even if you make more money.
Some folks don’t understand that social security maxes out each year; they think if they earn $800k, they are paying social security taxes on the whole amount. (I often see this mistake when people work a W-2 and a 1099. If their W-2 pays out above the wage base, then they don’t need to pay SS taxes on their 1099 side gig).
You do pay Medicare taxes on the whole amount (1.45% for each the employer and employee) but the social security tax (6.2% for each) stops at the wage base. So, how much is the social security wage base? Well, it changes every year.
Above, you can see the social security wage base (the maximum amount you are taxed on for the purposes of social security every year).
As a high earner, you stop paying FICA taxes above the wage base. But of course, this limits the amount social security credit you earn each year as well. That the point of this blog…. What are the social security bend points and how do you maximize them even if you retire early?
Now, you understand that even if you earn infinity one year, you will not max out your social security.
Next, we need to take inflation into account, as money used to be worth more than it is today.
Social Security Index Factors and Bend Points
Social security indexes past wages due to inflation.
Once you are 62, these indexes are set in stone and used to calculate your AIME. That is, social security assume you will keep earning income every year unless you are 62. If you retire early, you cannot use the AIME or PIA numbers they provide, you must calculate them yourself (since you won’t keep earning income). Once you are 62, AIME can go up if you keep working but it will not go down.
AIME: AIME is Average Indexed Monthly Earnings. It takes your top 35 index-adjusted years and then applies that to the bend points in order to calculate your PIA.
PIA: PIA is primary insurance amount. It is the monthly benefit you might be eligible for (which is decreased if you file early, and earns delayed retirement credits if you delay filing social security).
Ok, back to social security index factors: what is $100 of income worth towards your AIME over the past decades?
Above, you can see the index factor that is used when multiplying past incomes.
Note that $100 earned back in 1960 is the same as an income of $1350 in today’s dollars (its index factor is 13.5 and change). Another way to think about this: at least according to social security, your money is worth 13.5 times less now than it was 60 years ago. Good to know that.
Look through the decades: how much is $100 of earnings is worth? Next, note the decrease in the index factor. The index factors change every year (until you are 62, then they are set for you) depending on the amount of inflation each year. For the last 3 years, the index factor is stuck at 1.
To finish up above, here are the rest of the numbers. In 2000 you get $168, in 2010 it is $130, and since the index factor is 1 in 2020, $100 is worth $100.
In summary, the wage base is smaller in the past, but you multiple it times an index factor to take inflation into account.
Isn’t social security fun?
Finally, we are ready to get to the bend points.
What Are Social Security Bend Points?
So, what are social security bend points? These are the points when AIME starts paying you less.
The way it works: the first dollars you contribute to social security pay you more than the last dollars, because of the social security bend point percentages.
Above, you can see the social security bend point graph (which use 2020 numbers). Along the bottom is your AIME, which then is translated to your PIA.
You can see (blue) for every dollar of AIME up to the first bend point, you get 90 percent back. Then (red), every dollar provides you 32 percent. Finally, above the second bend point (green) you get 15 percent, and above the max (yellow), any additional amount you pay in social security taxes does not increase your PIA.
Here are the bend point numbers for 2021:
At an AIME of $996, you get 90%. This is the first bend point.
Next, the second bend point is between $996 and $6,002. There, you only get 32% back.
Finally, above that amount, you only earn 15% of your AIME. And above $11,900 (the third bend point), you no longer increase your PIA.
The maximum PIA in 2021 (this is the largest monthly check you can get) is $2324 at 62, and $3113 at Full Retirement Age. (If you get your delayed retirement credits, then at 70 the maximum check is currently $3895.)
By the way, to get the maximum amount, you would have needed to earn the maximum wage base back in 1986 (it was $42,000) and continued to earn above the wage base for 35 years.
So, in summary, the first few dollars you earn in social security credits are valuable to you, as you get 90% credit for them. After that first bend point, you only get 32% to the second bend point, and 15% above that until you hit maximum social security.
On to the main point of the blog: how many years does it take a high earner to get to their first and second bend point?
How Many Years Does It Take to Get to the First Bend Point?
How many licks does it take to get to the center of a tootsie roll pop? Or, more accurately, how many years do you have to be a high-income earner to hit the first bend point?
The answer is 3. After three years of maximal earning (using the three most recent years with an index factor of 1), you have an AIME above $966.
So, in summary, during the first three years of being a high-earner, you get back 90% of the money you put into social security. The social security bend point percentage on your first three years of work is 90%.
Of course, you actually need 40 credits of income to be eligible for social security. Since you can get 4 credits a year, you need to work for at least 10 years to get any (personal) social security benefits.
Let’s look now at where you fall in the break points after 10 years.
Bend Points After 10 Years
Where are we in the bend points after 10 years?
Above, you can see we have earned 10 years’ worth of income above the wage base.
Our AIME is $3229, well below the second bend point at $6002.
Just cause we have a second here, check on the index wages on the far right. Note that each year is a little bit different as the wage base and index factor changes every year. Each year averages out to about $135k of wage per year that counts toward your social security over time.
Let’s look at one more example: How many years of above the wage base earning does it take to hit the second bend point?
How Many Years Does It Take to Hit the Second Bend Point?
So, how many years do you have to work a high paying job to hit the second bend point?
This is pretty important to understand as you only get credit for 15 cents on every dollar contributed after this point.
Above, you can see that it takes 19 years to hit the second social security bend point.
That means for a high-income earner, from year 20 to 35 you only get 15 cents credit for every dollar you contribute to Social Security. To me, that is a pretty good reason to retire early!
I want to thank Physician on Fire for his bit on bend points. The Graphs above can be found at his blog.
Summary: How can you maximize your social security bend points?
In summary, you get full credit (90 cents on the dollar) for the first three years you work above the wage base.
Then, you get 62 cents per dollar from year 4-19. Years 20-35 you get 15 cents.
It is worth working an extra year if you can get your AIME above the first bend point. Once you are past the second bend point, it may be time to find a different job.