Reinvesting Dividends

When Should I Stop Reinvesting Dividends?

When to STOP Reinvesting Dividends?

Some people think you always should reinvest dividends. Others think perhaps there are times when you should stop dividend reinvestment.

Clearly, there is a place for dividend reinvestment. So when should you stop it?

What is Dividend Reinvestment?

First, what is dividend reinvestment?

This is a little different than DRIP, which I mention below.

When you sign up for an account, you generally decide what you will do with your dividends. You can either take them as cash (which gets deposited into your sweep account), or you can automatically buy more shares of the fund with the dividends.

Folks like dividend reinvestment because it is cheap, easy, automatic, and allows you to buy fractional shares through dollar-cost averaging resulting in compounding growth.

What is DRIP?

DRIPs are dividend reinvestment plans offered by individual companies on their stocks. Mutual funds, ETFs, and low-cost brokerages don’t have DRIPs; they have automatic dividend reinvesting, which can be turned on or off.

Reasons for Dividend Reinvestment

Automatic is the key to all the reasons to automatically re-invest dividends in equity holdings. You can take better advantage of compound growth when you reinvest dividends back into purchasing more shares.

In addition, there is less cash drag. Instead of spending time in the sweep account earning less than zero point nothing percent, your money can compound and earn dividends on the dividends!

Reasons not to Reinvest

There are a few reasons you might want to stop auto reinvesting.

One is control. If you attempt to adjust your Asset Allocation, manually re-invest the dividends in the sweep account. Asset allocation and risk are joined at the hip.

In addition, if you are tax-loss harvesting, you need to worry about wash sale rules. If you sell something in your taxable (brokerage account) to harvest the loss, you shouldn’t be buying back shares (in any account) for 31 days.

Some say it is easier to take distributions directly from the sweep account rather than having to sell shares to liquidate money. However, if you are living off your investments, you might as well have cash waiting for you rather than having to sell off shares.

So, should I reinvest dividends?

Should I Reinvest Dividends?

If you want to know if you should or should not reinvest dividends, we need to learn more about the account type you are dealing with.

Account Type and Dividend Reinvestment

Retirement Accounts

Since there are no tax liabilities associated with buying, selling, capital gains, or dividends in retirement accounts, it is optimal to reinvest dividends in these pre-tax retirement accounts automatically. Lack of cash drag is one of the most significant advantages; you are always fully invested. Learn more about your 401k, 403b, 401a, and 457 retirement accounts, where you should usually continue to reinvest dividends.

Brokerage/Taxable Accounts

In taxable accounts, debate about reinvesting dividends is common.

Automatic dividends are likely best if you are a low-maintenance, hands-off, or infrequent investor.

If you contribute monthly to different taxable investments or want to do tax-loss harvesting, then turn off the automatic dividend reinvestment.

When to Stop Automatic Dividend Reinvestment

When you are 5-10 years from retirement, you should stop automatic dividend reinvestment.

This is when you need to be moving from your accumulation asset allocation to your de-risked asset allocation. This is De-Risking your Portfolio Prior to Retirement.

Between 5 and 10 years before retirement, you are transitioning from 70/30 (or 100/0) down to 50/50.

50/50 or whatever your asset allocation is at the peak of Sequence of Return Risk. Consider a Bond Tent!

To make this transition, stop automatic dividend reinvesting, and every 6-12 months, re-invest as per your new asset allocation. Go Conservative!

This might give you larger lots if you use specific identification of shares that let you be efficient when harvesting capital gains during early distributions.

It can also simplify your tax reporting when you take income out of your brokerage account to live on. If you need the money to spend, just spend it! Stop reinvesting dividends.

Accumulation vs. Drawdown (vs. Transition)

In Summary: When in accumulation, reinvest dividends.

When in transition or drawdown, don’t! Especially in your brokerage account!

One final point. Always remember that money is fungible!

Money is Fungible, or, Do You Need Dividend Reinvesting?

Remember, money is fungible, so it is all the same. It doesn’t care where it came from, where it is going, or what account it is in. Money is Money!

Do what is easiest for you and what makes sense! There is no real advantage one way or another since money is fungible.

If this is just more than you want to know, then just reinvest dividends and don’t worry about it.

Should I reinvest dividends is only an issue because you are given a choice whether to do it or not, rather than a choice that really makes all that big of a difference.

Posted in Investments and tagged .

4 Comments

  1. Don’t forget, you will only wash the dividend amount, so it’s not a huge loss. For example, if you TLH $2,000 and have $75 of dividends reinvested, you only wash $75, not the entire $2,000, so not a huge deal.

  2. Great post about a topic most do not consider enough. The advice regarding tax loss harvesting/wash rule impact as well as using dividends to gradually change your portfolio allocations in a tax efficient manner is spot on.

    Thanks for what you do!

  3. I started transferring the dividends into my checking account from municipal bond accounts I inherited when I retired 2 years ago. It’s helped me not have to dip into my retirement accounts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *