Retirement Spending Smile or Lumpy Expenses?
The Retirement Spending Smile is one way to consider expenses in retirement. After years of setting money aside for the future, the future is now!
If you have saved enough to retire, you need to look at all your retirement income sources and figure out what you have to spend.
You have ‘guaranteed’ lifelong sources of income, such as social security, pensions, and income annuities. These can floor your income, providing a steady source for your needs during retirement. Other sources of income, such as business and rental income, may also be more or less continuous income streams.
In addition, you have your investment assets, such as stocks and bonds. These provide a variable source of income and are best suited to provide for your wants.
But before we talk about retirement income, we need to consider expenses.
What are the expenses during retirement? Are they constant? Are retirement expenses like a “smile” or perhaps more “lumpy” than that?
Let’s explore spending in retirement by evaluating the Retirement Spending Smile vs. Lumpy Retirement Expenses.
Retirement Spending Smile vs. Lumpy Retirement Expenses
Retirement Spending Smile
The retirement spending smile loosely describes overall spending in retirement. The idea is that spending gradually decreases during retirement, especially on fun things (variable expenses). But, of course, if you live long enough, there will be increased spending late in life on medical and personal care expenses.
The retirement spending smile above in figure 1 demonstrates real spending (black line) decreases with time. The initial slope of the decrease is rapid and flattens over time.
Health expenditures, however, manifest later in life. These expenses are uncertain and variable and increase with Age.
Lumpy Expenses and Retirement Spending Shocks
Variable expenses, on the other hand, pop up during retirement as well. But, again, these are either known or unknown.
Known lumpy expenses include automobile purchases, vacations, and routine but unscheduled home issues such as new HVACs and roofs. In addition, one could assume that common uninsured health expenses, such as dental and hearing aids, also fit into the known lumpy expenses.
Unknown lumpy expenses or spending shocks include unexpected health care expenses (major medical issues), family expenses (like failure-to-launch children and aging parents), divorce, and last but certainly not least, the loss of a spouse.
Smile vs. Lumpy
So, are retirement expenses like a smile and decrease with Age, or lumpy like the price of a stock? They are, of course, both!
Let’s look at each model of retirement expenses to optimize retirement spending and thus retirement income planning. How do you want to model your expenses in retirement?
Lumpy Expenses to Watch out for in Retirement
Let’s talk about what might constitute a lumpy expense in retirement.
What are some lumpy expenses to be aware of?
Perception of Lumpy Expenses in Retirement
It is interesting to see which lumpy expenses people worry about. Compare what current retirees worry about vs. what they think their parents’ concerns were.
First, the red bars represent retirees’ experience of lumpy expenses. The yellow bars show what retirees think their parents’ spending shocks were.
Retirees believe they have more home issues, dental issues, and market losses than their parents.
More interesting than that, look at what people think their parents’ issues were! Illness, disability, loss of capacity, and Medicaid are all issues more likely to happen to my parents than to me! Interesting!
What can we learn from this? Perhaps, we need to worry more about illness, disability, and loss of capacity. We see these issues reflected in our parents but are less concerned about these serious issues personally.
A List of Actual Lumpy Expenses
What are the lumpy expenses we need to consider in retirement?
Taxes not infrequently are well-to-do retirees’ largest expense. One with significant resources outside of social security should expect 85% of their social security to be taxable as part of ordinary income. On the other hand, the Tax-Torpedo is a lumpy tax issue faced by those with fewer resources during retirement.
Aside from social security, pension income and pre-tax accounts are taxable at ordinary income rates. How do you get a lumpy tax problem? Having other lumpy expenses and pulling money out of your pre-tax accounts to pay for them.
The flip side of this is a tax-deductible lumpy expense. There are times when one gets a tax deduction and SHOULD pull extra money out of pre-tax accounts to harness the lower tax brackets exposed by the tax deduction.
After running out of money, healthcare is the largest concern for retirees.
The healthcare system is broken, and the lack of price transparency is a major issue. From surprise out-of-network charges to catastrophic illness or ambulance/helicopter bills that aren’t covered, you never know when you will need to reach into your billfold or purse to pay medical bills.
Above a floor, healthcare costs can be deducted from your income. This is a slightly confusing topic, and it doesn’t help that the IRS changes the floor from 7.5% to 10% back to 7.5% again.
When are you subject to lumpy medical bills?
Healthcare is such a concern I want to spend some time looking at the lumpy costs associated with it. Above are out-of-pocket medical expenses by Age. Note that median spending is the highest at age 90-94, when health care spending is pretty common.
The 95th percentile out-of-pocket expenses stay pretty flat until above age 85.
Key Point About Lumpy Medical Expenses
This brings me to a key take-home point. Concerns about lumpy medical expenses are common. However, it is important to note that most folks have medical insurance in retirement. So, while medical costs are common lumpy expenses, they are often mitigated by the presence of insurance.
As represented by figure 3, the median cost of health care doesn’t go up significantly over time. With insurance, health care costs are more of fixed expenses. However, the distribution curve has expensive outliers or a fat right tail. Note the 95th percentile costs are going up sharply late in life.
I fear long-term care expenses. Chances for lumpy expenses are high.
Statistics, however, are misleading because ‘the industry’ wants you to be scared enough to buy Long-Term Care insurance. Statements like “70% need long-term care at some point in their life” are absurd! This is the percentage of folks needing some service during their lifetime. A much smaller proportion of people get through the 90-day elimination period and begin accessing insurance benefits.
I don’t like traditional Long Term Care insurance. But unfortunately, we may see these policies implode in the next two decades.
I don’t like hybrid insurance either. Most folks with lumpy long-term care costs can use these as tax deductions, allowing tax-free withdrawals of pre-tax money. This is a difficult concept, and the insurance salespeople haven’t figured it out yet.
The money pit. Major housing expenses are common lumpy expenses. Home retrofits for medical issues are also of concern.
This is a good lumpy expense! Take a cruise around the world.
Supporting kids, grandkids, or parents with gifts can be lumpy expenses. For example, is your daughter’s wedding considered a gift?
Pets are important for psychological health and can be expensive!
Loss of a Spouse
Spousal loss is inevitable, but the timing is uncertain. Becoming a widow or widower has huge financial ramifications, which are not often considered when making a retirement spending plan. The Widow Tax Penalty can be devastating under the right circumstances.
Summary: Lumpy Expenses in Retirement
There will be lumpy expenses! Consider the idea of “consumption smoothing.” This is a concept whereby retirees seek consistent spending in their retirement and pre-retirement years.
Consumption smoothing is not probable. A better solution is a cash bucket in retirement. This is not a 3-6 month “emergency fund,” this is a cash bucket of 2-3 years set aside for spending. You would refill this bucket yearly from your other assets to smooth consumption over the years.
Let’s move on to the Smile!
The Retirement Spending Smile
Some find it difficult to start spending in retirement after decades of saving.
Also, during economic downturns, it is the natural tendency for most folks to cut back even during retirement. This might be a form of self-insurance– running out of money is one of the largest concerns for retired people.
The trend in general, however, as we saw above, is a gradual decrease in spending over the majority of retirement until healthcare costs start to increase late in life. This is the retirement spending smile!
Let’s look at some issues with the Retirement Spending Smile, which are important to consider.
Inflation and the Retirement Spending Smile
Above, you can see the inflation-adjusted spending as a continuous dark blue line. This means you take out the same inflation-adjusted amount over the 30 years. It is an example of how you would plan future spending using, for example, the 4% rule.
However, real spending decreases for the first 15-20 years of retirement and increases rapidly in the last five years before death. Note the spending smile does not get above the inflation-adjusted amount until the last year or two of life.
Digging a little deeper, the Smile depends on the resources available for retirement.
Effect of Income on the Retirement Spending Smile
Affluent retirees have a different smile curve than those with limited resources (such as just social security). Those with plenty of reserves rapidly decrease the spending rate in early retirement, while those with fewer resources have a different curve. This implies a bit of flexibility in the decrease of spending in retirement.
This is represented above in figure 5. The blue line represents folks with less income. The decreasing slope is slow and not as deep as those more affluent in green. The rate of increase in the curve is higher and faster in those with less reserve, and they have increased real spending above inflation-adjusted amounts at the very end of their retirement.
Conclusion: Retirement Spending Smile vs. Lumpy Retirement Expenses
So, How Much Can I Spend in Retirement?
The retirement consumption puzzle states that spending decreases in inflation-adjusted terms during retirement. Yet while planning for retirement, we plan constant or even increasing spending goals.
The basic 4% Safe Withdrawal Rule method simulates spending that keeps pace with inflation. Unfortunately, this may result in having too much money left over at the end while not spending early enough in retirement on things you enjoy!
Planning to need ever-increasing amounts of income in the future restricts what can be spent early in retirement!
There are, however, known and unknown lumpy expenses that must be accounted for throughout retirement.
Nevertheless, all of this argues for more liberal spending early in retirement.